Strange thing with me that I have never been able to find a satisfactory way to conduct my life for more than six months. With regards climbing, just to contextualize the subject, I go through major swings in motivation and interest, ranging from an all-consuming fiery desire to always be on rock... to utter indifference. The syndrome I have uncovered, however, encompasses much more than my climbing addiction; it permeates my day to day life to an extent I had never before considered.
My hypothesis is that I suffer from a strange personality disorder that manifests itself through the endless warring of two diametrically opposed philosophical precepts at the core of my being: asceticism and hedonism.
Asceticism is a way of life that embraces qualities such as restraint, discipline, rigor, frugality, sobriety, abstinence and austerity. It seeks to simplify and purify life from futile worldly pleasures. The goal of an ascetic lifestyle is not to deprive oneself of pleasure and happiness. Rather, asceticism is founded on the notion that self-restraint and discipline will lead to greater forms of happiness, and peace, and enlightenment, through the forsaking of vain and unproductive occupations. It may sound high-flown, perhaps even a bit religious (the concept does have religious origins I believe), but in practice it is rather simple; the idea is to cultivate the mental discipline that will allow you to let go of immediate gratifications in order to achieve goals that are more rewarding on the long haul. I believe in the righteousness of this lifestyle with all my being.
Hedonism, at the other end of the spectrum, holds that the greater happiness is found through maximizing pleasure and avoiding pain. It is brain dead obvious: pleasure, good. Pain, bad. Go for the former, avoid the latter. Hedonist thought does not see the point in spending any significant amount of time indulging in unpleasant practices, and will argue that the pursuits of the ascetic are pointless inasmuch as they involve imposing upon oneself unnecessary pains. In other words: life is short. You spend your life abstaining yourself from everything, and then you die--a wasted life. The classic example is that of the workaholic businessman who accumulates millions but never comes around to enjoying the fruits of his labor, i.e. an Aston Martin. It's labor all the way through. Hedonism argues that we are hardwired to pursue sensual and intellectual pleasures. Trying to hold them back is unnatural, and certainly unhealthy. I also believe in the righteousness of this lifestyle with all my being.
So you see where I stand. Following are the daily dilemmas that leave me forever wanting for peace, satisfaction, and a clear mind.
My ascetic persona wants a healthy lifestyle governed by a disciplined and rigorous weekly routine: regular training sessions that include the rock gym, the hangboard, and some form of cardiovascular exercise, meditation sessions twice a day, a healthy diet brimming with fruits and vegetables, early bed times whenever possible, etc...
My hedonist self thinks that training requires too much willpower, and the results simply aren't worth the time invested. The only training for rock climbing should only be climbing... on rock.
The hedonist thinks that evenings are the best part of the day, when the kids are asleep, and I get to indulge in whatever suits my fancy: watching South Parks, playing Guitar Hero, blowing money on Full Tilt Poker, Facebooking, or some other time-wasting leisure. It doesn't see the point in sleeping and depriving me of enjoyable moments. It doesn't believe that a good night's sleep will make me considerably happier the following day.
The ascetic thinks that leisure time should be spent on constructive activities. Instead of killing time in front of TV or videogames or the internet, I should catch up on my reading, perhaps even do a bit of writing. My ascetic self understands that greater long term satisfaction will be derived from practicing and getting better at things that have more intrinsic value for me, like writing, or climbing. Hell, I could even finish my PhD dissertation if I really put my heart into it.
The hedonist disagrees. Leisure time should be spent relaxing, avoiding stress, and just having a good time. If that means fragging people on Call of Duty three hours in a row, than so be it.
The ascetic believes that most of the desires and needs I currently have are fake, trivial, and unnecessary, and that the key to self-fulfillment lies in getting rid of them, and that I should find a way to raise my children so that these false desires never arise in them. The hedonist thinks that such endeavors are lost causes; that it is hopeless to try and rid ourselves of desires and needs that media overwhelm us with every second of our lives. Refusing to acknowledge these desires, the hedonist holds, is condemning ourselves to living in endless cravings for things we deny ourselves without really being sure why.
The ascetic says that the lifestyle choices it proposes are much better to live a long and healthy life, and that if I don't eat well and exercise a lot I'll probably die from a coronary disease before my time. The hedonist says there are so many ways to die, it is pointless trying to avoid a few of them, since it is probably one of the others that will do you in. The hedonist is also a determinist.
The hedonist says I should be reading up on Epicurianism, and that there I will find my answers. The ascetic says the Zen budhists had it down pat, and that's where I should be heading.
And it goes on and on. Whenever I listen to the ascetic, the hedonist laughs, like it's saying "dude, this is no fun, what are you doing to yourself?" Whenever the hedonist has the better of me, which is most of the time, I can see the ascetic in the back of my mind shaking his head in despair, and guilt takes over.
Funny how we think we have free will, but most of the time it seems like most of the choices we have are made on auto-pilot, like we are the protagonist in Vonnegut's Timequake, forced to watch ourselves playing a fool's game over and over again.
Read more...
My book is off to the printers!
3 hours ago









